Bata to pay ₹9,000 fine for charging ₹3 for a paper bag

The Chandigarh Consumer Commission recently ordered Bata India Ltd to pay ₹9,000 in fine for charging ₹3 from a customer for a paper bag to carry the shoebox.

Legal experts say the order is legally valid across the country and that stores cannot charge consumers additional charges for the bag if the product is purchased from the same store.

The forum's order came on a complaint filed by a consumer, Dinesh Prasad Raturi.

Raturi told the consumer panel that he had purchased a pair of shoes on February 5 from the shoe store located in Sector 22D. The store charged ₹402, which also included cost for the bag.

Raturi contested that by charging him for the bag, Bata was also endorsing its brand on the bag which was not justified. Raturi sought a refund of ₹3 and compensation for deficiency in services.

The forum slammed Bata for charging an additional amount for the paper bag.

The forum ordered that a customer cannot be compelled to pay for the bag, and that it was a clear deficiency in service. The consumer forum ruled that it was the store's duty to provide a free bag to the customer who purchased their product.

Sagar Saxena, an advocate based in Delhi, said: "This consumer court's decision is legally valid across India. People can cite this order anywhere in the country and have the bag charges waived. The order establishes that even if the bag is environment-friendly, the retailer cannot charge an additional amount for the bag."

The consumer forum observed that if the companies are eager to protect the environment, they should provide free environment-friendly bags to the customers.

Nikhil Majithia, an advocate in Delhi, said: "After this order, the Ministry of Consumer Affairs should come out with guidelines to protect consumer rights. Shopkeepers are not allowed to charge extra from consumers, as they brand the bag with their logo, so it becomes part of their advertising."

The Chandigarh commission in its decision directed Bata India Ltd to refund the cost of the bag ( ₹3) and litigation charges, i.e. ₹1,000 along with ₹3,000 as compensation to the customer for the mental agony caused by deficiency in services.

The forum also directed Bata to deposit ₹5,000 in the legal aid account of the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission.

Comments

Top 10 trending phones of week 24

At a time when the number 1 and 2 remain the same as last week, a new number 3 is still exciting news. That would be the Samsung Galaxy J6, climbing two spots to join the Redmi Note 5 Pro and the Mi 8 on the podium. The OnePlus 6 seems to be bolted in fourth - that's its third week in there after claiming the top spot 4 weeks ago and quickly slipping into second the following one. The biggest gainer this week has to be the Redmi S2 (a.k.a. Redmi Y2) - entering the chart last week in 9th, it's now all the way up in 5th. The Galaxy A6+ (2018) is the second Samsung to climb two spots and we now find it in 6th, nudging the Nokia X6 into 7th. The Redmi Note 5 returns to the Top 10 in 8th spot after being absent for a couple of weeks, and long-time champion from a while back Galaxy J7 Prime makes a surprise appearance in 10th. In between them, we find the Oppo F7, cautiously advancing one spot ahead of its tenth last week. Xiaomi Redmi Note 5 Pro RANK: 1 WA...

Flipkart, Amazon hit as govt tightens e-commerce norms

The revised e-commerce norms come in the backdrop of several complaints by traders on deep discounts offered by Flipkart and Amazon The government has prohibited e-commerce companies from entering into exclusive deals for products. Tightening e-commerce norms for online retail firms, such as Flipkart and Amazon, the government on Wednesday took a host of steps and barred them from selling products of the companies in which they have stakes. The commerce and industry ministry also prohibited e-commerce companies from entering into exclusive deals for products. “An entity having equity participation by e-commerce marketplace entity or its group companies, or having control on its inventory by e-commerce marketplace entity or its group companies, will not be permitted to sell its products on the platform run by such marketplace entity,” the ministry said. Besides, the revised policy on FDI in e-commerce said that services should be provided by e-commerce marketplace entity o...

Zero: Katrina Kaif makes for a ravishing bride and we can't take our eyes off her. See pic

Katrina Kaif is busy shooting for Aanand L Rai's Zero, which stars Shah Rukh Khan and Anushka Sharma. The Jagga Jasoos actress posted a photo of herself from the sets, dressed in bridal wear. In the photo, we can see the actress wearing a peach lehenga. Heavy earrings and a nose ring complete her attire. So, we're guessing there's a wedding scene in the film. Katrina is playing an actress in the film, who struggles with alcoholism. SRK is playing the role of a dwarf. "While everyone thinks that only Shah Rukh Khan has a special role in the film with a disability, they will be surprised to know that Anushka and Katrina's characters also face various challenges. While everyone knows Katrina plays a diva, nobody knows that she is also an alcoholic in the film. She battles with alcoholism, which affects her life in various ways. Anushka, on the other hand plays a struggling scientist. The makers are trying to keep these details a secret because they don't...

Look in

Search This Blog